"A nomad I will remain for life, in love with distant and uncharted places." -Isabelle Eberhardt
"A nomad I will remain for life, in love with distant and uncharted places." -Isabelle Eberhardt
Book Review: Once Upon A River by Diane Setterfield
Aimee Geurts • December 26, 2018

I was beyond excited when I saw Diane Setterfield had a new novel coming out. Her novel, The Thirteenth Tale (2006), is one of my favorite books. I reread it every few years; reacquainting myself with Vida Winter, Margaret Lea, Adeline and Emmeline and John the Dig, as if they are my old friends. If you haven’t read The Thirteenth Tale , I can’t recommend it enough. However, read Once Upon A River (2018) first because nothing will live up to The Thirteenth Tale. In 2013 she released Bellman & Black , which I know I read but can’t really remember much about, so I must not have loved it too much.

Once Upon A River is rich with character development and backstory. The book is divided into the different family stories and the beginning spends much time setting up each family so that when they come around to join in the same story, their roles are clear. The two main family stories revolve around the Armstrongs and the Vaughns, each staking a claim to a little girl who is washed up along the shore of the river. She is either Amelia or Alice and neither family is quite sure, while both desperately want her to turn out to be the little girl they have each been missing.

Along the way, we learn more about the characters as we all try to figure out who the little girl is, to whom she really belongs. We also meet “talking” pigs, river boat photographers, a myriad of bad guys and voracious story tellers. In addition, the character named Quietly acts as the Grim Reaper of the river. Setterfield does an amazing job weaving the stories of all together. I enjoyed the story of the Armstrongs best, Robert and Bess, and the story of their relationship and family, and the way Robert was with every human and animal he met. While I still love The Thirteenth Tale the most, this book did not disappoint.

Further reading:

By Aimee Geurts November 11, 2024
I can't stop reading this poem.
By Aimee Geurts September 12, 2024
*This is not that hot of a take. It’s common knowledge but it’s more evident to me than ever.
By Aimee Geurts February 7, 2023
An Ode to Midge
Share by: